8. Historic Environment
 
OBJECTIVES
1 To preserve and enhance the overall quality of the historic environment of the County Borough. (aim 1)
2 To secure the preservation or enhancement of historically and architecturally important buildings and groups of buildings and their settings. (aim 1)
3 To protect ancient monuments and sites of archaeological and historic interest. (aim 1)
4 To protect historic parks and gardens and take full account of the historic landscape in determining planning applications. (aim 1)
   
   
POLICIES
Caerphilly County Borough has a rich and varied historic environment including listed buildings, conservation areas, ancient monuments, archaeological sites and historic parks, gardens and landscapes. This chapter puts forward policies to confirm and reinforce the statutory framework for protecting this historical and architectural heritage. The Policies in this Chapter therefore apply to 'development', namely any works that require planning permission, and also to 'proposals' for Listed Building Consent or Conservation Area Consent where that is appropriate.
   
  INTRODUCTION
8.1 To a great extent the County Borough's historic environment reflects development during the Industrial Revolution of the 19th and early 20th Centuries. Accordingly, many of the Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas are important civic, religious and industrial buildings and structures that form the architectural trademarks of that era. However, the most well known historic buildings and ancient monuments in the area pre-date this period by hundreds of years. These are the 13th Century Caerphilly Castle and the early 16th Century Llancaiach Fawr Manor House. There are many other similar buildings, monuments and archaeological sites in the County Borough which are not so well known but are of equal historical significance.
8.2 National planning policy guidelines i indicate that all of these buildings, structures and sites should be protected. The Government considers the preservation and enhancement of the historic environment a key aspect of Local Authorities' wider historic environmental responsibilities which should be taken into account in the formulation of planning polices and the exercise of development control. Cadw advises the Welsh Assembly Government in relation to ancient monuments, archaeological sites, historic buildings, conservation areas and historic parks, gardens and landscapes.
 
POLICIES
   
 
HE1 DEVELOPMENT AND PROPOSALS TO PRESERVE OR ENHANCE THE QUALITY AND CHARACTER OF THE HISTORIC ENVIRONMENT WILL BE PERMITTED
(Objective 1)
 
8.3 Buildings and the spaces around them contribute to the individual character of towns and villages. The topography, setting and historical influences of an area are all expressed in the design of its buildings. The Council would not normally wish to dictate the design of new buildings but is concerned that where development does take place, including alterations to existing buildings, the design should be sympathetic and of a high standard. When considering a building's design, developers should consider the relationship with its surroundings. This should be reflected in matters of scale, density, layout, height, massing, access, materials and landscaping.
   
Listed Buildings and Structures
 
HE2 DEVELOPMENT AND PROPOSALS AFFECTING LISTED BUILDINGS OR STRUCTURES WILL ONLY BE PERMITTED WHERE THEY WOULD PRESERVE THE CHARACTER AND QUALITY OF THE BUILDING OR STRUCTURE, AND/OR ITS SETTING
(Objectives 1 and 2)
 
8.4 There are currently 410 Listed Buildings in the County Borough. This figure has recently changed due to a survey of the 26 Communities of the County Borough undertaken by CADW. The Council places a high priority on preserving the architectural quality of the area, and accordingly, any new development should not have an unacceptable impact on the architectural or historic character or appearance of any of these buildings or their settings.
8.5 The listing of a building affects both internal and external aspects of its structure. Plans showing both existing and proposed details and a full schedule of all works will be required for consideration with all applications for works to listed buildings.
8.6 The Council recognises that the best way of preserving a building is for it to continue in beneficial use. Therefore, where the original use of a listed building has ceased, it may be necessary to accept a new use to ensure its preservation. The conversion, rehabilitation and improvement of listed buildings will only be acceptable where the architectural and historic features are being preserved.
   
 
HE3 DEMOLITION OF BUILDINGS WHICH ARE LISTED OR MAKE A POSITIVE CONTRIBUTION TO THE CHARACTER OR APPEARANCE OF A CONSERVATION AREA WILL NOT BE PERMITTED UNLESS THE BUILDING IS STRUCTURALLY UNSAFE AND CANNOT BE MADE SOUND FOR TECHNICAL OR ECONOMIC REASONS. SUCH APPROVAL WILL BE SUBJECT TO A CONDITION THAT, BEFORE DEMOLITION BEGINS, PLANNING PERMISSION IS OBTAINED AND A CONTRACT LET FOR APPROPRIATE REPLACEMENT OR REDEVELOPMENT
(Objective 2)
 
8.7 The procedures for demolition of a Listed Building and a building in a Conservation Area are essentially the same. Applicants proposing to demolish such a building must be able to justify their proposals and show why demolition is necessary. Only in exceptional circumstances will consent be given for demolition, and then only when every possible means of retaining the building has been examined. The replacement or redevelopment proposed must produce benefits for the community which outweigh the loss resulting from demolition. The Council has a statutory duty to pay special regard to the desirability of preserving listed buildings and their settings.
   
Conservation Areas
 
HE4 DEVELOPMENT, CHANGE OF USE, OR DEMOLITION WILL ONLY BE PERMITTED IN CONSERVATION AREAS, INCLUDING THE FOLLOWING, WHERE IT PRESERVES OR ENHANCES THE CHARACTER OR APPEARANCE OF THE AREA:
    1 BUTE TOWN
    2 RHYMNEY TOWN
    3 NELSON
    4 RUPERRA CASTLE AND PARK
    5 GELLIGAER
    6 GELLIHAF
    7 MAESYCWMMER / HENGOED
    8 GELLIGROES
    9 TREDOMEN
    10 CWMCARN MEMORIAL PARK
    11 GARDEN SUBURBS, PONTYWAUN
    12 LLANBRADACH
    13 GROESWEN
    14 DRAETHEN
    IN THE DETERMINATION OF PROPOSALS FOR DEVELOPMENT OUTSIDE A CONSERVATION AREA BUT WHICH WOULD AFFECT ITS SETTING FULL ACCOUNT WILL BE TAKEN OF THE DESIRABILITY OF PRESERVING OR ENHANCING THE CHARACTER OR APPEARANCE OF THE CONSERVATION AREA
(Objectives 1 and 2)
 
8.8 Conservation Areas are designated because they possess a particular historical or architectural character which the Local Authority considers should be protected. This does not mean that development will be resisted as a matter of principle, rather that when a development is proposed particular attention will be paid to its design to ensure that it is sensitive to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. There are fourteen designated Conservation Areas within the County Borough, all of which are shown on the Proposals Map. This policy applies to all designated Conservation Areas within the County Borough and also to any Conservation Areas designated under the appropriate legislation over the Plan period.
8.9 Within these areas, additional controls apply to new developments, changes of use and to demolition, to secure the long-term preservation and where appropriate enhancement of the special character for which they have been designated. A 'Character Statement' will be prepared for each of the Conservation Areas defining what it is about each area that makes it 'special', to set out what needs to be done to keep it special, and to determine how best to achieve this. Supplementary Planning Guidance will set out what type of alterations and developments are considered acceptable within each of the Conservation Areas, depending on the character of the individual conservation area. It is intended that this will be used in conjunction with these policies.
8.10 Special attention must also be paid to development proposals which are outside designated Conservation Areas but would affect their setting. The Council will seek to obtain the co-operation and participation of landowners, business communities and residents to promote positive schemes to enhance the architectural heritage of each Conservation Area.
   
 
HE5 DEVELOPMENT WITHIN CONSERVATION AREAS WHICH INCLUDE THE PROVISION OR REPLACEMENT OF ROAD OR FOOTPATH SURFACES, OR NEW STREET FURNITURE INCLUDING ADVERTISEMENTS, SHOULD BE SYMPATHETIC TO THEIR SETTING AND CONTRIBUTE TO THE PRESERVATION OR ENHANCEMENT OF THE CHARACTER OR APPEARANCE OF THE AREA
(Objective 1)
 
8.11 Powers are available to the Council to restrict permitted development rights and deemed consent for advertisements. Where it appears that the character of a Conservation Area may be harmed by inappropriate minor developments, the Council will consider the making of appropriate directions or designations to restrict development rights ii.
   
Archaeological Remains and Scheduled Ancient Monuments
 
HE6 PROPOSALS WHICH PROTECT OR ENHANCE SCHEDULED ANCIENT MONUMENTS AND THEIR SETTINGS WILL BE PERMITTED SUBJECT TO SATISFYING OTHER DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA. DEVELOPMENT WHICH CAUSES DAMAGE TO SCHEDULED ANCIENT MONUMENTS WILL NOT BE PERMITTED
   
(Objective 3)
HE7 WHERE THERE ARE ARCHAEOLOGICAL REMAINS OR WHERE THERE IS GOOD REASON TO BELIEVE THAT SUCH REMAINS EXIST, AND THEIR SETTINGS ARE AFFECTED BY A PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT, THERE WILL BE A PRESUMPTION IN FAVOUR OF THEIR PRESERVATION IN SITU. WHERE THIS IS DEEMED INAPPROPRIATE, PROPOSALS WILL BE SUBJECT TO A REQUIREMENT TO SECURE THE EXCAVATION AND RECORDING OF THOSE REMAINS AND IF APPROPRIATE THEIR REMOVAL IN WHOLE OR IN PART
(Objective 3)
 
8.12 Archaeological remains are a finite and an irreplaceable resource, in many cases highly fragile and vulnerable to damage and destruction. They can contain valuable information about our past and are important both for their own sake and their role in education, leisure and tourism. Some archaeological remains are scheduled as Ancient Monuments, but the vast majority of sites remain unprotected. Cadw is responsible for the care and maintenance of some Ancient Monuments. However, Local Planning Authorities have a number of key responsibilities in relation to archaeological sites and monuments within their areas.
8.13 National Planning Guidance iii requires that Development Plans must "reconcile the need for development with the interests of conservation including archaeology' and should 'include policies for the protection, enhancement and preservation of sites of archaeological interest and their settings". Policies HE6 and HE7 will provide an important part of the framework in considering each proposal for development that affects archaeological remains with the aim of guiding developers in preparing planning applications.
8.14 There are currently 46 Scheduled Ancient Monuments in the County Borough. This is only a small proportion of the wealth of historic remains in the area. The Glamorgan-Gwent Archaeological Trust, (GGAT), which provides the Council with a comprehensive planning service, has records of over 100 archaeological sites in the County Borough iv . Although the majority of sites are not legally protected and have no official status, their importance and significance should not be overlooked.
8.15 Where development is likely to affect a known archaeological site, or an area where there is good reason to suspect a significant archaeological interest, the Council may request the developer to arrange for an archaeological field evaluation to be carried out before any planning application is determined.
8.16 The Council will encourage any scheme that will preserve and where appropriate enhance Scheduled Ancient Monuments and other sites of archaeological or historic interest. It is important that they are not only preserved and enhanced, but also that their settings are protected and improved.
   
Historic Parks, Gardens and Landscapes
 
HE8 PROPOSALS WHICH HAVE A HARMFUL IMPACT ON THE APPEARANCE, SETTING, CHARACTER AND QUALITY OF THE FOLLOWING HISTORIC PARKS, GARDENS AND LANDSCAPES WILL NOT BE PERMITTED
    1 MAES MANOR HOTEL, BLACKWOOD
    2 THE VAN, CAERPHILLY
    3 RUPERRA CASTLE, RUDRY
    4 CEFN MABLY
    5 GELLIGAER COMMON
(Objectives 1 and 4)
 
8.17 Cadw, in association with the International Council on Monuments and Sites and the Countryside Council for Wales, has prepared a Register of Landscapes, Parks and Gardens of Special Historic Interest in Wales. The register has been prepared in two parts. The first, covering Historic Parks and Gardens, lists the above four Historic Gardens within the County Borough. The second, covering Historic Landscapes, lists Gelligaer Common as a Special Historic Landscape. No additional statutory controls follow from the inclusion of a site in the Register.
8.18 The County Borough Council will consult Cadw on planning applications in respect of Grade 1 and 11* sites and the Garden History Society on all parks and gardens listed in the register. Any necessary restoration or management which will enhance a site identified on the Register, will be encouraged. The scale, nature, appearance, design, layout, landscape treatment and traffic generation, are matters which ought to be taken into account in the implementation of the Policy.
 
 

i Planning Policy Wales, March 2002, Paragraphs 6.1.1 - 6.5.23
ii Provision is made to issue directions under Article 4 of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 or designations under part (iv) of the Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) Regulations 1992 to restrict permitted development or deemed consent rights where it appears that the exercise of such rights could be detrimental to the character or appearance of a conservation area
iii Welsh Office Circular 60/96, 'Planning and the Historic Environment: Archaeology'
iv The Regional Sites and Monuments Record is held and curated by GGAT. It consists of a series of databases which hold over 14,000 individual records of archaeological sites and finds for South Wales. Adoption of the record was a requirement of the Welsh Office Circular 60/96. The County Sites and Monuments Record, which was formally adopted by the Council in June 1997, is also held by the Trust
 
TopContents